Tonia Antoniazzi MP
  • Home
  • About Tonia
  • Latest News
  • Get in touch
  • Advice Surgeries
  • COVID-19 GOWER COMMUNITY RESOURCES

Tonia Antoniazzi MP: the reality of rail electrification

31/7/2017

3 Comments

 
Picture
If we're serious about transitioning to a low-carbon economy, electrified rail is a must.
​The Tories want us to think that bi-mode trains are a good for Wales, but here’s the truth about the benefits of electrification. ​​​​
Having a positive can-do attitude is essential as a new MP.  I have made my disappointment very clear in the media about the Tories letting us down.  They have failed to deliver electrification any further west than the capital city and instead of being branded a ‘Welsh whinger’ I just want to highlight WHY electrification is good for Gower, Swansea and further West.

This week, I pressed Sam Hadley from Network Rail on electrification and services to Swansea considering the Tory U turn on electrification. Welsh MPs and AMs now need to look forward and seek out ways to fund electrification. Having read the report by lead economist Gerry Haltham, we need to consider the options will deliver for Wales despite the Tory resistance to invest.

So why is electrification better? Electric trains offer the best train performance and lowest journey times compared to bi-mode trains.  They give a low noise passenger environment, when the bi-mode train uses its diesel engine there will be increased noise for those in the train and those living along the railway.  Currently the HST (High Speed Trains) have a diesel engine at both ends of the train unlike the diesel/electric bi-mode trains.  So, the noise of the proposed bi-mode trains will be worse for passengers.

The Welsh Government has a low carbon transition delivery plan in which electrification would be a key feature. We should therefore be focused on leading the transition to low carbon – to lay the foundations for a better future and maximise the long-term benefits to Wales along the way. Therefore, electrification is part of reducing Wales’s dependency on oil and future oil variation.
 
We need to be looking at a more joined up approach to energy and our transport infrastructure in Wales.  Electricity from renewable energy such as solar and tidal can provide for electric trains and cars across Wales. More significantly in my opinion for Wales, electrification opens potential for additional regional electric services to integrate not only Swansea and Cardiff but the rest of Wales.
3 Comments
Gerald Holtham
1/8/2017 08:51:09

Dear Ms Antoniazzi
I am delighted that you are taking up this issue. The UK government is not going to change its mind but the Welsh government can step into the breach and, in my opinion should do so, for all the reasons you cite. It is affordable. The interest rate on 30-year British government bonds is currently below 2 per cent. The Welsh government could surely obtain permission to borrow to electrify to Swansea. Network Rail would be happy to do it in a joint venture with the Welsh government. An electric loco maintenance facility was being constructed in Swansea which is now being dismantled. That facility and associated jobs could be restored.
I hope other MPs and AMs from South West Wales will demand action too.
Yours truly
Gerald Holtham

Reply
Amanda Ellis-Evans
1/8/2017 13:24:40

Come on people of Swansea lobby your Councillors, MP, AM, Uncle Tom Cobley and all Dint accept this decision; support Tonia with her campaign!

Reply
David Rees
1/8/2017 15:08:20

I agree full heartedly with Gerald Holtham. Yet again it's a sign that unless Wales takes a stance for itself and shows that the British Government have no interest in the the prosperity of Wales, let alone the health and well being of its people.Wales has no bargaining chip, it does not have the political position of Northants Ireland, or the oil reserves of Scotland, but it does have a people with foresight and a belief in themselves to progress as a Nation. Cardiff Wales Airport was decaying and the private ownership showed little faith in its future, now it is going new levels of business by the day whilst under ownership of the Welsh Assembly, I see not reason why the same faith should be put into the electrification of the railways in Wales.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    News Archive

    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    January 2020
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    January 2018
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017

    Categories

    All
    Weekly Update

Contact Tonia
PRIVACY POLICY
  • Home
  • About Tonia
  • Latest News
  • Get in touch
  • Advice Surgeries
  • COVID-19 GOWER COMMUNITY RESOURCES